For the Critic

You want the weak points, not the pitch. Here they are, ranked by severity, with nothing rounded away.

1. 1
   Theorem S.1 has no proof text

   The single highest-risk finding in the entire manuscript audit.
2. 2
   Existence of W* is unproven

   The central selection mechanism's own existence claim is open.
3. 3
   Open Problems

   Every unresolved criticism, tracked publicly.
4. 4
   Failed & Blocked Tests

   What couldn't be run, and exactly why.
5. 5
   SPARC data is absent

   The dark-matter account's most direct observational test isn't run.