Skip to content
Structural Selection
Lemma A.2In a file corrected during the v2 audit

Lemma A.2normalization singles out $p=2$

Formal statement

\emphFor a fixed normalized ψ\psi and orthogonal decomposition H=iPiH\mathcal H=\bigoplus_iP_i\mathcal H, iψip=1\sum_i\|\psi_i\|^p=1 holds for every such decomposition if and only if p=2p=2. Proof. By Parseval/Pythagoras, iψi2=ψ2=1\sum_i\|\psi_i\|^2=\|\psi\|^2=1 for every orthogonal decomposition, so p=2p=2 works. For p2p\ne2, iψip\sum_i\|\psi_i\|^p depends on the decomposition (e.g. for ψ\psi an equal superposition of dd orthonormal terms and PiP_i the corresponding rank-1 projectors, iψip=d1p/21\sum_i\|\psi_i\|^p=d^{1-p/2}\ne1 for p2p\ne2), so wi:=ψipw_i:=\|\psi_i\|^p is not a context-independent, automatically normalized weight for any p2p\ne2. \blacksquare

Hence the squared-norm measure is singled out by the correct mechanism (automatic normalization, Lemma A.2), together with local additivity (Lemma A.1) — not by tensor-product-composition stability, which does not distinguish p=2p=2 from any other exponent.

Source

Appendix A. Technical and Measure-Theoretic DetailsBorn Rule from Stability & Measure Geometry

03_BornRule_From_Stability_MeasureGeometry/08_Appendix_A.tex

Revision history

This source file received at least one correction during the v2 audit — see the changelog for the exact change; not every statement in the file was necessarily the one corrected.

Read this result in context on its source chapter page, or submit a criticism if you believe this statement, as given, is incomplete or incorrect.